Kate's Cakes Chicago

Initial Business Response / [redacted] (1000, 5, 2014/05/11) */ When Ms[redacted] emailed us to let us know that she did not like the cake, her email started out (verbatim): "Hi***, everyone loved the cakeThe presentation was awesomeIt was delicious." She informed us about the spots, and attached pictures of the cut cakeThere were spots, but we understood that perhaps she was not satisfied with the quantity of themOur response, verbatim, was: i'm glad that you enjoyed the cake! I do apologize that you were disappointed with spotsAs shown in the pictures, there were spots, but perhaps not enough? to amend the situation, i'd love to give you 10% off your next cake order with kate's cakes Chicagoit was a pleasure working with you, and we do hope to get the chance again." If Ms[redacted] had wanted some sort of refund, while we would not have refunded half, as the part she wasn't happy with did not come close to half of the cake amount, and she was otherwise happy, we would have discussed this with her, had she informed us that some sort of refund or reimbursement was what she was afterWe would be fully willing to reimburse her the cost of the spots, as that was what she felt she paid for but did not receive Initial Consumer Rebuttal / [redacted] (3000, 7, 2014/05/27) */ (The consumer indicated he/she DID NOT accept the response from the business.) Ms [redacted] 's response is unacceptable, just as her original offer to settle (10% discount on a future cake order) was unacceptableMs [redacted] pain and simply did NOT produce theitem she reassured me she wouldA sample photo of what I wanted was sent to [redacted] via emailA contract was drawn up by Ms [redacted] herself, describing the details of the cake wantedLEOPARD PRINT SPOTS INSIDE THE CAKE...Again the reason for choosing***'s Cakes Chicago was because I was guaranteed in writing that she could do the jobAttached is a photo of he same sample photo sent to Ms [redacted] along with the finished productSample photo on the left/finished product on the rightI bagged about how spectacular the cake was to beInstead it was just another baby shower cakeI am seeking the refund of half the paid amountAlso, more documentation will be sent via U.SPostal Service, including the cake contract and emails shared between [redacted] and myself

Initial Business Response /* (1000, 5, 2014/05/11) */
When Ms.*** emailed us to let us know that she did not like the cake, her email started out (verbatim): "Hi***, everyone loved the cakeThe presentation was awesomeIt was delicious." She informed us about the spots, and attached
pictures of the cut cakeThere were spots, but we understood that perhaps she was not satisfied with the quantity of themOur response, verbatim, was: i'm glad that you enjoyed the cake! I do apologize that you were disappointed with spotsAs shown in the pictures, there were spots, but perhaps not enough?
to amend the situation, i'd love to give you 10% off your next cake order with kate's cakes Chicagoit was a pleasure working with you, and we do hope to get the chance again."
If Ms.*** had wanted some sort of refund, while we would not have refunded half, as the part she wasn't happy with did not come close to half of the cake amount, and she was otherwise happy, we would have discussed this with her, had she informed us that some sort of refund or reimbursement was what she was afterWe would be fully willing to reimburse her the cost of the spots, as that was what she felt she paid for but did not receive
Initial Consumer Rebuttal /* (3000, 7, 2014/05/27) */
(The consumer indicated he/she DID NOT accept the response from the business.)
Ms***'s response is unacceptable, just as her original offer to settle (10% discount on a future cake order) was unacceptableMs*** pain and simply did NOT produce theitem she reassured me she wouldA sample photo of what I wanted was sent to*** via emailA contract was drawn up by Ms*** herself, describing the details of the cake wantedLEOPARD PRINT SPOTS INSIDE THE CAKE...Again the reason for choosing***'s Cakes Chicago was because I was guaranteed in writing that she could do the jobAttached is a photo of he same sample photo sent to Ms*** along with the finished productSample photo on the left/finished product on the rightI bagged about how spectacular the cake was to beInstead it was just another baby shower cakeI am seeking the refund of half the paid amountAlso, more documentation will be sent via U.SPostal Service, including the cake contract and emails shared between*** and myself