Sign in

Park Avenue Rarities, Inc.

Sharing is caring! Have something to share about Park Avenue Rarities, Inc.? Use RevDex to write a review
Reviews Gold Buyers, Coin Dealers, Supplies Park Avenue Rarities, Inc.

Park Avenue Rarities, Inc. Reviews (22)

Elder Fraud
My 80 year dad was contacted last year by Park Avenue rarities. Over a 4 month period he purchased 113k of coins. They called him multiple times a week about coin deals, gold and silver. These guys are sleazy NY trash and would not stop calling after we reached out several times about not calling and harassing our dad. My dad had the start of dementia and these guys took total advantage of his situation. I took the 113k of coins to two local dealers near where I live. Total value $40,000. My dad was scammed $73,000 and we have no recourse. Park Avenue Rarities should be put in jail. NEVER buy from these people. They are total trash.

+1

They did the same thing to my family. First class criminals. One of their employees stole coins from us to make it worse and we can't get our money or coins back.

Return address
Does anybody know the address for coin return? They are giving me the run around, they said they would charge me 20%, my invoice says I have 15 days for return.

+2

If this issue is not resolved as yet, phone Carrigan Anthony, 888-826-2706; Carrigan may help to solve your problem.
I just purchased 1921 silver COINS (hope it's silver dollars, but maybe not). Carrigan did not mention a 20% "coin return." To my knowledge their address is: 173 N Main St, Ste 232, Sayville, NY 11782-2512
(I wasn't told about a UPS Store .. sort of a cell company ya think?) If they are NOT reputable I would be surprised and quite disappointed. I'll have the new arrival checked out in So Cal.

Return policy
I want to return some coins that I guess I ordered and I am getting the run around, they tell me there is a 20% stocking fee tht I will be charged but my invoice says if returned within 15 days you get a full refund but like I said 20% stocking fee thats not right plus I need the address for these coins to be returned, you call them and no answer you send a text no response, never again with this company.

+1

A bunch of Sopranos wannabes
On Sept 29 I ordered and was billed for a $1,700 coin. It was authorized by their credit, card person card person. I got it two days layer, signature required. Then they billed me for a coin or two every couple days and would mail it signature required once a week; until my credit car maxed out at $18,000. They do not have voice recordings of my order nor signatures of me receiving these coins. Bob Green is running a den of thieves and he's rude and foul mouthed. They should be dealt with. Anybody want to join me? Steven Pettinga 317 251-7009. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPq9Y-Djhnc

+1

HARASSMENT AND FRAUD!!!!!!
Do not deal with these people they are thieves! We bought a few coins and then covid hit so no more! These people not only sent us coins we did not order they grossly over charged for them! Of course we sent them back immediately signature required and guess what they said they didn't get them. Busted! We called credit company reversed charges then we got the card statement and these jerks used our credit card to go out for lunch! They keep calling harassing us trying to call for someone else knowing exactly who they are calling! One more call I'm pressing charges! Don't even get involved with these low life's. Spend your money on someone who actually deserves your business! These guys are bullies and thieves and liars!

But a total of 42 coins from Park avenue rarities. was told that all the coins were uncirculated and at least ms65 engraved. I sent the coins to NGC to have them graded. It cost me approximately $1,000 to have them graded. All the coins came back circulated in some even came back cleaned. called Park avenue and told them. After a couple of months of haggling with them I finally asked for my money back and requested they refund the money it cost me to have the coins graded. they refunded me the money and I return the coins. They would not refund me the money for having the coins graded. now I am still requesting to have the money refunded from having the coins graded and they are refusing to answer my calls. I have now contacted the attorney general of the state of New York.

Poor sales etiquette
Received a call late afternoon. Salesperson with heavy NY accent talked nonstop. When I told him I wasn't interested, his comment as he hung up was "Aw, you're a jerk"! I will never do business with them, and I will never refer another client or business associate to them under any circumstances.

Revdex.com: I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID [redacted] , and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me and the matter has been resolvedconsumer called 3/*/and stated that he received the coins, so his case is resolved Sincerely, [redacted]

This is in response to ID# [redacted] , [redacted] placed the order on 102014, his product was delivered 102014, he contacted us and said he was not happy with the product he purchasedWe told him to send the items back for a full refundHe said that is fineThe next day he not only sent us back the product but called the Revdex.com as well [redacted] did not give us a chance to even refund his moneyMonday morning we received his product back and issued a full refundWe spoke to [redacted] that day and he was very pleased with the outcomeWhen I spoke to him again on he stated he was going to call his local Revdex.com and drop the complaintAs you can see the complaint was made very quickly, just day after we spoke to himWe never had a chance to make things rightPlease take this complaint off of our businessWe pride ourselves in having such a great reputation in our business, and with our clients and we don't want this complaint to look poorly on us Sincerely, [redacted] Park Avenue Rarities

Revdex.com: I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID [redacted] , and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me and the matter has been resolved See attached Sincerely, [redacted]

The owner Bob Green is a low life person,,,He will do anything for a sale,,,He is totally underhanded and cannot be trusted...Bob agrred to allow me to retuen an item, then charged me a fee which he said he would waive then overcharged me $1000 on the next purchase intentionally,,DoNOT use this coin dealer,,,

+5

At this time, I have been contacted
directly by Park Avenue Rarities, Inc. regarding complaint ID ***, however my complaint has NOT been resolved because:consumer called 3/*/and stated that he received the coins, so his case is resolved
Sincerely,
*** ***

+2

I received my 2.5 and 5 dollar gold indian gold pieces March 16 and was concerned about their authenticity and returned them asking for a full refund and sears credit card did credit my account only to have Park Avenue Rarities recharge my credit card on may 24 without my permission in May and denying I ever returned them in the first place When I realized that they had done this I immediately called sears that they had recharged my account and I wasn't due this for 3200 dollars I asked them if they wanted my receipt from the postal service they said not to just yet that they would see what they could do. Meanwhile the time frame is over to dispute my claim and Sears wont do any thing.

This business needs to be shut down. Better to go to your local coin dealer so you can see what you are getting.

This is in regards to a purchase I my or not have make to Part Ave. Rarities located in Sayville NY. When I say may or may not have I just don't remember this purchase. I have been in the hospital three times this year and my memory is a little down now. It will come back but I may never remember a few days after the last time in the hospital. Anyway I have used and bought from this company before. They call me one day with a offer of the life time. They first told me it was a 1911 or 13 $5.00 old coin. I don't buy coins at this price range because of the amount of money. Some way my no was turned to a yes and my Visa card charged. I have never received any official notification that the coin was here. After I saw the charge on the card I do believe I called them and they didn't even ant to talk.
In the first place the coin is over valued and not worth that much money. No I don't know how it was ordered and I can not believe I would have ordered it. I called a friend that grades coins for NGS one of the larger company that grade coin. He told me the coin was way over priced and I also know it not worth it. I have tried to dispute the coin with my bank and haven't had any luck. I wold like to talk to these people and get another coin of the correct value are reduce the coin to what it cost, And I know they have to make a profit. But talking has not worked out and I would like to settle this. Thank You for any help or guidance you could provide. I just want a fair shake and get what I pay for.
John McGowan
139 Mill Creek Dr.
Fitzgerald Ga. 31750

This is in response to ID# [redacted], [redacted] placed the order on 10/**/2014, his product was delivered 10/**/2014, he contacted us 10/**/2014 and said he was not happy with the product he purchased. We told him to send the items back for a full refund. He said that is fine. The next day...

10/**/2014 he not only sent us back the product but called the Revdex.com as well. [redacted] did not give us a chance to even refund his money. Monday morning 11/**/2014 we received his product back and issued a full refund. We spoke to [redacted] that day and he was very pleased with the outcome. When I spoke to him again on 11/**/2014 he stated he was going to call his local Revdex.com and drop the complaint. As you can see the complaint was made very quickly, just 1 day after we spoke to him. We never had a chance to make things right. Please take this complaint off of our business. We pride ourselves in having such a great reputation in our business, and with our clients and we don't want this complaint to look poorly on us.
Sincerely,
[redacted]
Park Avenue Rarities

Revdex.com:
I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID [redacted], and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me and the matter has been resolved.
consumer called 3/*/15 and stated that he received the coins, so his case is resolved.
Sincerely,
[redacted]

Revdex.com:
I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID [redacted], and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me and the matter has been resolved.  See attached
Sincerely, [redacted]

Review: I was contacted by phone by someone with Park Avenue Rarities and was given a sales pitch about purchasing some Kennedy half dollars (20 of them) for $495. I was told they were like proofs, un-circulated. I told them I was not at all interested. Two days later, I got the same call again. I finally agreed to purchase them, believing that they would be in excellent, near-proof condition. I was told they were at LEAST worth the $495. When I got them, the condition wasn't that great. I took them to a local coin dealer and he said the whole lot of them wouldn't be worth even $100 because the condition was not near-proof condition. I called Park Avenue Rarities said to return the coins, but that included another sales pitch telling me that coin dealers in Idaho don't know what they're doing (which is untrue - a coin dealer is a coin dealer). I'm really nervous to return them and then have them keep my money.Desired Settlement: I'm going to return these coins in the condition I received them in and I would like an assurance from this business that I will get my full $495 back.

Business

Response:

This is in response to ID# [redacted], [redacted] placed the order on 10/**/2014, his product was delivered 10/**/2014, he contacted us 10/**/2014 and said he was not happy with the product he purchased. We told him to send the items back for a full refund. He said that is fine. The next day 10/**/2014 he not only sent us back the product but called the Revdex.com as well. [redacted] did not give us a chance to even refund his money. Monday morning 11/**/2014 we received his product back and issued a full refund. We spoke to [redacted] that day and he was very pleased with the outcome. When I spoke to him again on 11/**/2014 he stated he was going to call his local Revdex.com and drop the complaint. As you can see the complaint was made very quickly, just 1 day after we spoke to him. We never had a chance to make things right. Please take this complaint off of our business. We pride ourselves in having such a great reputation in our business, and with our clients and we don't want this complaint to look poorly on us.

Sincerely,

Park Avenue Rarities

Consumer

Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID [redacted], and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me and the matter has been resolved. See attached

Sincerely,

Review: In January 2016 I ordered by phone 1 roll of Ben Franklin Gem proof coin for $600. They have a stated return policy of full refund within 15 days .Before coins arrived I changed my mind and decided to purchase silver eagles instead. I phoned company and they said to return coins and they would send eagles. I returned package of coins un opened but have received nothing although the salesman, John S[redacted] said they sent a package that was lost, then said they would send another one which, of course they did not .My last conversation with them was over a week ago. They never return calls and seldom accept calls.Desired Settlement: Refund of money

Consumer

Response:

At this time, I have been contacted directly by Park Avenue Rarities, Inc. regarding complaint ID [redacted], however my complaint has NOT been resolved because:consumer called 3/*/15 and stated that he received the coins, so his case is resolved.

Sincerely,

Consumer

Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID [redacted], and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me and the matter has been resolved.consumer called 3/*/15 and stated that he received the coins, so his case is resolved.

Sincerely,

+1
Check fields!

Write a review of Park Avenue Rarities, Inc.

Satisfaction rating
 
 
 
 
 
Upload here Increase visibility and credibility of your review by
adding a photo
Submit your review

Park Avenue Rarities, Inc. Rating

Overall satisfaction rating

Description: GOLD, SILVER & PLATINUM DEALERS, COIN DEALERS, SUPPLIES, ETC.

Address: 173 North Main Street, Suite 232, Sayville, New York, United States, 11782

Phone:

Show more...

Web:

www.parkavenuerarities.com

This site can’t be reached

Shady, yet now dead: once upon a time this website was reported to be associated with Park Avenue Rarities, Inc., but after several inspections we’ve come to the conclusion that this domain is no longer active.


E-mails:

Sign in to see

Add contact information for Park Avenue Rarities, Inc.

Add new contacts
A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z | New | Updated